Comics for Halloween · Part 21

Long Lost

Matthew Erman and Lisa Sterle send two sisters into the woods, but the trouble they have talking to each other is what makes the journey worth following.

Matthew Erman · Lisa Sterle

Read the full review →
Book page & reading status →

Family trauma, estrangement, disturbing creatures, threat to a pet, violence, and strong language. This review focuses on the opening setup, the sisters, and the artwork without revealing the ending.

Narrated with on-screen captions. Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Inside the book

After Piper’s dog disappears, a cloaked visitor invites her and her sister Frances to their mother’s birthday in Hazel Patch. Going back means facing the family and the place they remember differently.

Find your next read after Long Lost →

Read the video transcript

Something has taken Piper’s dog. Now a stranger in a cloak is holding out an invitation. To her mother’s birthday party. Apparently, she’s going home.

This is Long Lost, written by Matthew Erman, with art by Lisa Sterle. Part twenty-one of Comics for Halloween.

Piper wants to be left alone. She has a little dog named Pockets, a house, and a phone she doesn’t always answer. Her sister Frances gets worried enough to take a bus across the country to see her.

Then the visitor arrives. It knows their names. It wants both sisters back in Hazel Patch, the town where they grew up. And before it leaves, it warns them about the woods.

What pulled me in is how much trouble these two have talking to each other before anything supernatural happens. Frances wants to be close to her sister. Piper keeps pushing people away.

On the drive home, Frances explains what she wants. To feel appreciated. Considered. Acknowledged. She’d like to be able to say she’s friends with her sister. You can feel how hard it is for Piper to answer.

Erman lets them interrupt each other, make jokes, get defensive, and say things they can’t quite take back. Then something horrible happens, and they still have to get back in the car together.

That mixture gives Long Lost its personality. A hooded creature delivers a terrifying invitation, and Frances’s response is to hit it with a stick. The humor makes them feel like people you could know, even as their surroundings become harder to explain.

And Lisa Sterle makes both sides work. A raised eyebrow or a sideways glance tells you exactly how a remark has landed. Then she puts those expressive, recognizable people somewhere you can’t make sense of.

Woods crowd around them. Branches crowd around old houses. Figures stand among the trees. The visitor’s mask comes away, and what’s underneath makes you want it put back. Everyday scenes use black, gray, and cream. Darker sequences sink into cold blues and greens.

But the image I keep coming back to is simpler. Two sisters sitting beside each other, trying to work out how to be in each other’s lives. They remember the same family differently. And loving someone doesn’t mean agreeing about what happened to you.

The creatures give that journey teeth. The sisters give you a reason to follow it. Long Lost is a complete twelve-issue story, now collected in one volume for the first time by Vault Comics. Would you go back to the place you grew up if someone you loved needed you there?