Comics for Halloween · Part 25

The Silver Coin, Vol. 1

A struggling musician finally gets people to listen. What he is willing to explain away makes the first story in this cursed-object anthology especially uncomfortable.

Michael Walsh · Chip Zdarsky · Kelly Thompson · Ed Brisson · Jeff Lemire · Toni Marie Griffin

Read the full review →
Book page & reading status →

Graphic violence, gore, strong language, bullying, and disturbing imagery. The review discusses Ryan’s choices in the first story without recounting its ending.

Narrated with on-screen captions. Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Inside the book

A silver coin moves from person to person, changing lives and leaving violence behind. The first volume opens with Ryan, whose struggling rock band suddenly sounds extraordinary after he finds the coin among his mother’s old things.

Find your next read after The Silver Coin, Vol. 1 →

Read the video transcript

Heads, you lose. Tails, you lose.

You know that feeling during a horror movie when someone reaches for something, and you want to tell them to leave it alone? Reading The Silver Coin, you start feeling that way every time someone picks up that cursed coin.

The first issue starts with something you can understand: wanting your life to finally go somewhere. Ryan’s band is struggling. Then he finds a coin, uses it to play guitar, and suddenly they sound incredible. His bandmates ask if it’s cheating. Ryan calls it “the ultimate producer.” For the first time, people are listening.

I understand why he wants to keep using it. And now that he knows what the coin can do, he’s going to use it as far as it’ll take him. “No matter what.”

When a chance at success means leaving his bandmates behind, he takes it. At the next performance, his fingers start to bleed. But he keeps playing. “No matter what” becomes: “I can’t stop.”

Walsh makes the performance look exhilarating. Then the color becomes overwhelming, and the crowd starts to feel threatening. The thing Ryan wanted is becoming something I want him to escape.

And before you’ve quite shaken that feeling, you’re onto the next issue. You’re at summer camp. Different people. A different decade. A girl runs into the woods to get away from the kids tormenting her. Inside a cabin, she finds a blade. There’s a coin in the handle. She doesn’t know what she’s found. You do.

The Silver Coin carries that dread through different kinds of horror. The third issue follows a robbery that goes wrong. Someone steals the coin, and an escape into the snow leads somewhere you really don’t want them to go.

The fourth jumps centuries ahead. Police drones. Human implants. Digital money. And somehow, this cursed coin is still here.

I wanted to see where it would turn up next. How the same coin could bring a different kind of nightmare to whoever found it. Each new writer gets to take the curse somewhere different. Michael Walsh draws every story, holding those worlds together.

His cluttered rooms and exhausted faces make these people feel like they had difficult lives before the coin ever arrived. You want some of them to catch a break. Others make it much harder to care. But you start worrying about anyone who gets close to them. And with each story, you bring a little more fear into the next.

I’d pick this up for Halloween if you like short, vicious horror stories that leave you bracing for another. Because eventually, someone else finds the coin. And you have to watch them pick it up.