The Silver Coin, Vol. 1 cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

The Silver Coin: What Would You Explain Away to Keep It?

A struggling musician finally gets people to listen. What he is willing to explain away makes the first story in this cursed-object anthology especially uncomfortable.

The book

A silver coin moves from person to person, changing lives and leaving violence behind. The first volume opens with Ryan, whose struggling rock band suddenly sounds extraordinary after he finds the coin among his mother’s old things.

Michael Walsh · Chip Zdarsky · Kelly Thompson · Ed Brisson · Jeff Lemire · Toni Marie Griffin

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A good Halloween pick when you want short, vicious horror stories with a continuing sense of dread. The first story makes Ryan’s desire for a break easy to recognize, then lets you watch the excuses grow. Michael Walsh’s worn rooms, exhausted faces, and sudden flares of color keep the damage close.

Read it if

You like horror anthologies, cursed objects, desperate bargains, and characters whose wishes make them vulnerable. Start here for the first five stories in the larger series.

Maybe skip if

You want gentle scares or one continuous cast to follow. The book changes people and settings, and its stories can be cruel and graphically violent.

Content note

Graphic violence, gore, strong language, bullying, and disturbing imagery. The review discusses Ryan’s choices in the first story without recounting its ending.

The thing that would finally fix your life

More money. A little fame. Someone finally noticing you. It is easy to imagine the thing that would make life feel different. The uncomfortable question is what you would explain away once you finally had it.

In the opening story of The Silver Coin, written by Chip Zdarsky and drawn by Michael Walsh, Ryan finds a coin that transforms his struggling rock band’s sound. Suddenly people are listening. His bandmates wonder whether using it is cheating. Ryan calls it the ultimate producer.

His mother left the coin behind when she walked out. He wonders whether it helped her leave. There is already a reason to be uneasy about this thing, and Ryan decides that he will use it for as far as it will take him. No matter what.

The choice that makes the promise real

When a record label wants disco, Ryan’s bandmates say no. Ryan goes anyway. That decision is where his promise to use the coin starts to cost someone else something.

Ryan wants the chance to get signed. His bandmate wants to keep the music they already share.The Silver Coin, Vol. 1 · Chip Zdarsky (writer) · Michael Walsh (art, colors, and letters) · Image Comics. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

I can understand wanting a break. Wanting to stop feeling powerless. Wanting something to finally go your way. Watching Ryan made me wonder how much I would explain away before admitting that something was wrong.

The story gives those feelings a direction. A useful object becomes something he depends on, and the confidence of no matter what turns into the fear of not being able to stop. The people around him have to live with the difference.

Worn rooms and sudden color

Michael Walsh makes these worlds feel worn and grubby. Cramped rooms and exhausted faces give the supernatural something ordinary to get into. The shadows gather around people who already look as though they have been through too much.

Then the color flares. A concert turns red. A face disappears into cold blue shadow. A sudden red detail stops your eye in exactly the place you wish you had not looked. Those changes make the images feel volatile without losing the people inside them.

The concert floods with red and pink. Walsh turns the performance into a sudden flare of color inside this worn-down world.The Silver Coin, Vol. 1 · Chip Zdarsky (writer) · Michael Walsh (art, colors, and letters) · Image Comics. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

That visual continuity matters as the anthology moves between writers and settings. A seventies rock band, a summer camp, and a dystopian future can belong to different kinds of horror while still feeling touched by the same object.

The coin keeps moving

The first volume collects five issues, with stories by Chip Zdarsky, Kelly Thompson, Ed Brisson, Jeff Lemire, and Michael Walsh. Walsh provides the book’s principal art and also writes the fifth issue. Each change of hands gives the coin another person to work on.

The people change, and you start worrying about everyone around them. By the next story, the sight of the coin is enough to make you nervous. Knowing that it has arrived does not tell you which particular wish or weakness will give it room.

I would pick this for Halloween if you want brief, vicious stories you can read one at a time. Start with Volume One, and watch the choices as closely as the cursed object. If it finally gave you what you wanted, would you let it go while you still could?

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from The Silver Coin, Vol. 1

Shelves from The Silver Coin, Vol. 1

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 25

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:49 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Nameless cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 26

Nameless

Grant Morrison · Chris Burnham · Nathan Fairbairn · Simon Bowland

An asteroid is heading for Earth. An occult symbol is carved into its surface. Then the signal arrives, and stopping the impact begins to feel like the least of the crew’s problems.

Read Part 26 →