Criminal, Vol. 1: Coward cover

Crime · Spoiler-light review

Criminal: Coward Review: Why Leo Knows When to Run

Everyone knows Leo will run when a job goes bad. Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips make that instinct feel like the smartest thing about him, right up until someone he loves needs him to stay.

The book

A crooked cop wants a police transport robbed, and he needs Leo Patterson to plan it. Leo knows better than to work with cops. Then Greta, whose husband died on an earlier job, tells him what the money could mean for her daughter.

Ed Brubaker · Sean Phillips · Elizabeth Breitweiser

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A complete heist story with a real stake in who gets out. I believed Leo could get himself out. I wanted him to get Greta out too.

Read it if

You like crime stories where you can follow the planning and still see exactly why someone breaks his own rules.

Maybe skip if

You want a flashy caper with quick banter. The planning here sits alongside grief, family history, and the difficulty of getting out.

Content note

Violence, addiction, dementia, and grief. This review covers the setup and leaves the outcome of the heist and the ending for the book.

The rules that keep Leo alive

When I heard Criminal was being adapted for Prime Video, I wanted to go back to Coward. Leo’s the guy people call when they need a job planned, and the guy they make fun of for leaving the moment it goes bad. He knows his exit before he says yes. He has a rule about working with cops. If he’s scared, he’s paying attention.

Phillips shows you how practiced that thinking is early on. Leo changes into cycling gear and rides past the police. I liked seeing an escape play out at the pace of someone who had already thought through what he’d do when the job fell apart.

Why he says yes

Greta lost her husband on the previous job. She remembers that Leo kept her off the crew. Now she wants enough money to move her daughter out of the city, and she has her own reasons to take this chance.

The people around Leo grew up hearing about the same jobs and the same men. He looks after Ivan, who worked with Leo’s father and now sometimes calls Leo by his father’s name. Those details make you feel how long this life has been pulling people back in.

Heavy shadows and a reason to stay

Phillips draws the streets and rooms in heavy shadow. He gives you just enough of a face or a gesture to see someone weighing an option. Watching Leo pay attention is one of the pleasures of the book, especially when everyone else assumes they know what he’ll do.

Leo’s still thinking things through by the time the job asks more of him. He’s willing to take risks he would never take for a payday. That’s what made me want him and Greta to get out.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from Criminal, Vol. 1: Coward

Shelves from Criminal, Vol. 1: Coward

Crime stories where consequences surface years later12 booksDesperate choices that lead deeper into danger11 booksEveryday American places steeped in criminal dread11 books

Watch the video review

Criminal, Vol. 1: Coward

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:51 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next