Old Boy cover

Crime · Spoiler-light review

Old Boy Manga Review: Why the Ending Works

Someone pays to keep Shinichi Goto in a room for ten years, then lets him out. The explanation divides readers. Its smallness is what makes it so disturbing to me.

The book

Shinichi Goto spends ten years in a private prison with a television and meals pushed through the door. Released without explanation, he starts tracing the routine he knew best, including the taste of his takeout.

Garon Tsuchiya · Nobuaki Minegishi · Kumar Sivasubramanian · Kathryn Renta

The verdict

A patient crime manga about two men who have given years of their lives to the same grievance in very different ways. It gives you something to argue about after the mystery is solved.

Read it if

You enjoy watching someone reason through a mystery, and you’re willing to sit with an answer that feels out of proportion to what was done.

Maybe skip if

You’re after the pace or specific ending of Park Chan-wook’s film. The manga spends more time with Goto’s investigation and builds to its own explanation.

Content note

Abduction, prolonged confinement, and violence. The review talks about the effect of the ending and leaves both the manga’s motive and the film’s reveal undisclosed.

He remembers the food

Somebody keeps Goto alive in a room for ten years. When he gets out, one of the first leads he can follow is the Chinese food delivered to him there. He tries restaurant after restaurant, hoping to recognize the cooking.

I love that his miserable routine now gives him something to work with. I also kept wondering how much of his next move had already been anticipated. The man responsible keeps calling and setting conditions, even after Goto walks free.

A night sky after ten years

Minegishi has kept us looking at the bed, the television, and the door where the food comes in. Then Goto gets outside and suddenly there’s an enormous night sky. The release feels physical because the room has had time to become familiar.

Later he eats, smokes, and watches people. You can see his face soften, then watch him start assessing the room when someone wants a fight. The pleasure he takes in being alive matters as much to me as how dangerous he can be.

Why the motive stays with me

Park Chan-wook’s film gives you a motive you can grasp immediately. The manga asks you to spend time with a grievance whose explanation can seem absurd. Something Goto barely remembered became the thing another man built his life around.

The punishment feels wildly out of proportion. That’s what makes the ending work for me. Goto loses ten years and still finds things to enjoy. The man who held him was free that whole time and spent it feeding the same resentment.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore crime comics

Shelves from Old Boy

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Old Boy

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:47 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next