When Wishes Go Bad · Part 02
What We Wished For
Six friends get the wishes they made as kids, 35 years after they made them. Ilias Kyriazis finds warmth and dread in the distance between what those children wanted and what the adults need.
Ilias Kyriazis · Nikki Spanou · Tom Williams
Grief, a parent who no longer recognizes his daughter, coerced affection, gender and exclusion, and crude humor. This review discusses several wishes and leaves their final outcomes for the book.
Narrated with on-screen captions. Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.
Inside the book
A being in a cave offers six childhood friends one wish each. Nothing seems to happen until the wishes start coming true decades later, when the friends have jobs, families, and lives their younger selves could scarcely have imagined.
Find your next read after What We Wished For →
Read the video transcript
What if a wish you made as a kid came true today? You’ve changed. The wish hasn’t.
In What We Wished For, six childhood friends discover a cave, and a being inside offers each of them one wish. Nothing seems to happen. Then, decades later, their wishes start coming true.
This is What We Wished For, by Ilias Kyriazis. Part two of When Wishes Go Bad. These people have jobs, families, disappointments.
But their younger selves suddenly get a say in their lives. Stella wished for endless cakes. But cake can’t fix everything else she’s carrying, including a father who no longer recognizes her.
Patrick wished for his childhood crush to fall in love with him. Now she has a life of her own. What happens to her choices when his wish takes over?
And Angie wished to be a boy, because being a girl meant getting left out. When that wish arrives, it changes her body. But her story also asks what she’s spent her life believing about what being a woman means.
Dale wanted superpowers. His story takes that fantasy somewhere much darker. Michael’s story gives the book a different kind of weight.
He’s grieving his father. His childhood wish was to be the world’s best skateboarder. That won’t bring his father back.
But watching him rediscover that joy gives the wish a different meaning. It doesn’t have to solve his whole life to give him something worth having. The art changes with them, too.
Childhood has a simpler, more cartoonish look. Adulthood feels more detailed and lived-in. And that montage of music, movies and history makes the years between those lives feel tangible.
The book moves quickly between its cast. Some threads get less room than others. But there’s room for warmth alongside the crude humor and darker turns.
The wishes bring these friends back into each other’s lives, and force them to look at what those lives have become. One complete, standalone graphic novel from Humanoids. Would you still want your childhood wish?
Or are you relieved it never came true?
Watch next
All video reviews →
▶ 2:39When Wishes Go Bad · Part 01
Eight Billion Genies
You can ask for exactly the right thing and still have to survive everybody else’s choices. Charles Soule and Ryan Browne follow that problem from the first eight seconds to entire societies built around a wish.
Watch review →
▶ 1:38Comics for Halloween · Part 31
Exquisite Corpses: Season One
Twelve killers enter a town on Halloween night. The harder part is remembering the people who live there once you start enjoying the fight.
Watch review →
▶ 1:59Comics for Halloween · Part 30
Clean Room
Astrid Mueller looks like a cult leader because she is one. The uncomfortable part of Gail Simone’s horror comic is what happens when you begin to believe she may also be right.
Watch review →