What We Wished For cover

Fantasy · Spoiler-light review

What We Wished For: When Your Childhood Wish Finally Comes True

Six friends get the wishes they made as kids, 35 years after they made them. Ilias Kyriazis finds warmth and dread in the distance between what those children wanted and what the adults need.

The book

A being in a cave offers six childhood friends one wish each. Nothing seems to happen until the wishes start coming true decades later, when the friends have jobs, families, and lives their younger selves could scarcely have imagined.

Ilias Kyriazis · Nikki Spanou · Tom Williams

The verdict

A warm, sometimes crude standalone graphic novel about what happens when your younger self gets a say in your life. The book moves quickly across six stories, and some could use more time.

Read it if

You like supernatural stories about old friendships, adult regrets, and the smaller joys people find after a loss.

Maybe skip if

You prefer each member of an ensemble to get equal time, or want a gentler take on the fallout from wishes.

Content note

Grief, a parent who no longer recognizes his daughter, coerced affection, gender and exclusion, and crude humor. This review discusses several wishes and leaves their final outcomes for the book.

A wish that took 35 years

What if a wish you made as a kid came true today? The friends who find the cave have no idea what their adult lives will look like. By the time the wishes arrive, their younger selves are making decisions for people with whole lives of their own.

Stella gets the endless cakes she asked for. That still leaves her with a father who no longer recognizes her. The silliness of the wish makes the gap between what she wanted then and what she needs now easy to feel.

Who else gets a say?

Patrick wished that his childhood crush Bianca would fall in love with him. Bianca has built her own life in the years since. Watching the wish take hold makes it hard to ignore what Patrick’s fantasy costs her.

Angie wished to be a boy because being a girl meant getting left out. When the wish changes her body, Kyriazis gives her room to reckon with what she has spent years believing about being a woman. Dale’s childhood desire for superpowers goes somewhere darker still.

A little joy can be enough

Michael is grieving his father when he gets his childhood wish to become the world’s best skateboarder. Watching him rediscover the joy of skating gives the wish a different meaning. One good thing can matter in the middle of grief.

Kyriazis gives childhood a simpler, more cartoonish look and draws adulthood in more lived-in detail. A montage of music, movies, and history helps us feel the years in between. I wanted more time with some of the friends, but I liked the warmth that kept surfacing when the wishes brought them back together.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore fantasy comics

Shelves from What We Wished For

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

When Wishes Go Bad · Part 02

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:17 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Puella Magi Madoka Magica cover

When Wishes Go Bad · Part 03

Puella Magi Madoka Magica

Magica Quartet · Hanokage · William Flanagan · Alexis Eckerman

Sayaka can heal someone she cares about with one wish. The miracle works, which makes the terms Kyubey leaves out even harder to face.

Read Part 03 →