One good Halloween
Jimmy loves horror and his mom knows exactly how to get him excited for Halloween. When she surprises him with a twelve-foot lawn skeleton, he almost wants to send a picture to his dad. The way she turns away tells you how much is behind that little moment. I wanted someone to let this kid have a good night.
Across the street, Lola wants Halloween with her brother to feel the way it used to. Both kids have reasons to want a few hours of ordinary fun, and that’s what made their stories stick with me.
Trouble on the bus
The bullying on Jimmy’s bus is vicious. A scene where a chiropractor tries to toughen up his own son with a painful adjustment is harder to sit with than anything the decoration has done so far.
That father veers close to a cartoon villain, and I’d trade a few pages of setup for more time with the skeleton. The book already gives us enough to want better for these kids.
The glow of the pumpkins
Ben Templesmith makes the street feel like somewhere you could walk. The pumpkins glow against cold blues, with fallen leaves and familiar houses putting you in a Halloween you recognize.
I’m coming back for the kids and to see what happens to those neighbors. By the last pages, there’s every reason to think the street is going to feel different the next time we visit.


