Exquisite Corpses: Season One cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

Exquisite Corpses: They Had Plans for Tomorrow

Twelve killers enter a town on Halloween night. The harder part is remembering the people who live there once you start enjoying the fight.

The book

Thirteen powerful families secretly control the country. Every five years, twelve challengers send killers into a competition hosted by the reigning family. This time the arena is Oak Valley, Maine, and its residents have not agreed to be part of the game.

James Tynion IV · Michael Walsh · Jordie Bellaire · Becca Carey

The verdict

A brutal, readable first season that makes excitement about its killers uncomfortable by keeping the town’s residents close. The first thirteen issues give the night an ending; this review covers that full season, rather than only the opening collection.

Read it if

You want slasher spectacle with clear action, an ensemble of dangerous entrants, and ordinary people whose interrupted lives give the violence a cost.

Maybe skip if

You want restrained violence, a small cast, or horror that keeps its spectacle separate from the discomfort of enjoying it. This is a thirteen-issue commitment across three collections.

Content note

Extreme graphic violence, gore, coercion, and threats to a community and children. The review discusses the game’s premise and early character situations without identifying survivors or revealing the ending.

A town someone else chose

Twelve killers. One town. Halloween night. Exquisite Corpses has the immediate appeal of a lineup you want to watch collide: a rabbit-masked killer, a nurse, a recluse, and a collection of other dangerous entrants with their own presence.

James Tynion IV and Michael Walsh place that spectacle inside a game run by thirteen families, one for each original American colony. The reigning family hosts; the other twelve send killers. The winner’s family gets to rule until the next competition.

This year the families have chosen Oak Valley, Maine. They buy off the sheriff, cut the phones, and seal the roads. The residents become part of a contest whose rules and rewards belong to someone else.

They have plans for tomorrow

Audrey is stuck at work while her son goes trick-or-treating. Xavi is trying to reach his boyfriend. Laura is a paramedic on what should be an ordinary shift. Those are the lives the game interrupts.

They have plans for tomorrow. You are watching people bet on whether they will make it there. That becomes a nasty feeling when, a few pages earlier, you were excited to see the rabbit guy fight.

The book makes that change in attention matter. It gives you reasons to follow the entrants, then keeps returning to people who have nothing to gain from being in the same town. The violence has an audience inside the story, and it becomes difficult to feel entirely separate from it.

You know whose driveway it is

Walsh and the rotating artists make Oak Valley feel recognizable. The town has homes, streets, and people with somewhere they were supposed to be. When a fight breaks out, you know whose driveway it is happening in.

The fights are brutal, but you can follow them. Clear action keeps the encounter readable without making the injuries feel incidental. You understand what someone has done to another person and where the people around them are trapped.

Jordie Bellaire keeps the streets cold and dark, then floods the page with color at the moment of impact. Becca Carey’s lettering gives those impacts volume. The visual force makes the spectacle exciting while the residents give it something much harder to dismiss.

A season, not just an opening volume

Thirteen issues make up this first season, and they give the night an ending. The three collections divide it into issues #1–3, #4–8, and #9–13. The Volume One cover shown here represents the place to begin, not the whole season in one book.

The rotating team matters to that full-season scope. Writers include Tynion, Walsh, Pornsak Pichetshote, Che Grayson, Tyler Boss, and Bellaire; artists include Walsh, Marianna Ignazzi, Valentine De Landro, Adam Gorham, Claire Roe, and Gavin Fullerton.

What gives the season its weight is the thought underneath the contest. The families can afford to treat the town as an arena. The people who live there deserved a tomorrow.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore horror comics

Shelves from Exquisite Corpses: Season One

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 31

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

1:38 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next

Keep reading

All reviews →

You’ve reached the latest review in this series. Browse Comics for Halloween reviews →