Clean Room cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

Clean Room: How Much Would You Let Her Get Away With?

Astrid Mueller looks like a cult leader because she is one. The uncomfortable part of Gail Simone’s horror comic is what happens when you begin to believe she may also be right.

The book

After her fiancé’s involvement with Astrid Mueller’s organization ends in tragedy, Chloe Pierce sets out to expose its leader. The investigation draws her toward creatures Astrid claims to understand and a war that makes her methods harder to dismiss.

Gail Simone · Jon Davis-Hunt · Walter Geovani · Sanya Anwar · Quinton Winter · Todd Klein

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A disturbing, complete eighteen-issue horror story built around an excellent moral problem: believing Astrid does not make trusting her any easier. The first issue moves quickly, and the artwork changes hands in the final stretch, but the central discomfort is worth following.

Read it if

You want cult horror, institutional power, horrible creatures, and a lead whose apparent knowledge makes her behavior more difficult to judge.

Maybe skip if

You want a straightforward hero, a gentle opening, or consistent lead artwork across the entire run. Suicide and graphic body horror are central to the setup.

Content note

Suicide, coercion, cult abuse, graphic violence, and body horror. This review discusses the setup and visual approach without explaining the ending.

The person Chloe wants to expose

Chloe Pierce has every reason to distrust Astrid Mueller. Her fiancé joined Astrid’s organization. A video he received becomes the beginning of a tragedy, and Chloe goes looking for the person behind it.

Astrid has bestselling books, celebrity followers, and people who know how to make others cooperate. Those are recognizable signs of a dangerous organization. Gail Simone lets that recognition do useful work before the supernatural threat takes over.

Chloe goes in to expose her. Instead, she begins to see things too: creatures that ride people, wear them, and use them to do horrible things. The investigation no longer has the reassuring shape of an outsider discovering a fraud.

Being right does not make her safe

Astrid is recruiting soldiers for a war she believes is already happening. The difficult question is how much of her behavior becomes easier to excuse once you start to believe her.

The script keeps her terrifying even when her knowledge proves useful. Gratitude and cruelty can belong to the same person. Knowing something about the threat does not tell you what limits she will observe while fighting it.

That is the discomfort I would recommend the book for. It asks you to keep judging someone after the explanation you hoped would discredit her has become much less comfortable.

Bright rooms, nowhere to hide

Jon Davis-Hunt can make a conversation over tea feel threatening. The controlled faces and bright, clinical spaces leave the reader studying the people inside them.

Then an impossible body enters that clarity. The creature has too many mouths, or something inside a person becomes visible. The ordinary surroundings remain readable, which gives the intrusion very little distance from the reader.

Davis-Hunt and Quinton Winter’s color work belongs to that effect. The opening does not need to keep everything in permanent darkness. Brightness can make the horrible thing harder to avoid.

Eighteen issues of uncomfortable belief

There are caveats. The first issue sprints through its setup, and the art changes hands for the final stretch, with Walter Geovani and Sanya Anwar contributing alongside the principal Davis-Hunt run.

The series is complete in eighteen issues, collected in three volumes. That makes it a manageable commitment if you want to follow its central question through a finished story.

What stays with me is not only whether Astrid is right. It is how much I would let her get away with once I believed she was.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from Clean Room

Shelves from Clean Room

Unraveling mysteries with supernatural stakes8 books

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 30

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

1:59 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Exquisite Corpses: Season One cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 31

Exquisite Corpses: Season One

James Tynion IV · Michael Walsh · Jordie Bellaire · Becca Carey

Twelve killers enter a town on Halloween night. The harder part is remembering the people who live there once you start enjoying the fight.

Read Part 31 →