Comic review

Old Boy

Someone pays to keep Shinichi Goto in a room for ten years, then lets him out. The explanation divides readers. Its smallness is what makes it so disturbing to me.

Garon Tsuchiya · Nobuaki Minegishi · Kumar Sivasubramanian · Kathryn Renta

Abduction, prolonged confinement, and violence. The review talks about the effect of the ending and leaves both the manga’s motive and the film’s reveal undisclosed.

Narrated with on-screen captions. Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Inside the book

Shinichi Goto spends ten years in a private prison with a television and meals pushed through the door. Released without explanation, he starts tracing the routine he knew best, including the taste of his takeout.

Find your next read after Old Boy →

Read the video transcript

Bullshit.

That’s what I want to say when someone tells me the Oldboy movie is miles better than the manga.

Okay. Kind of kidding. You can prefer the movie.

But one of the biggest complaints about the manga is actually part of why it works for me.

Shinichi Goto spends ten years locked in a room.

Chinese takeout. A television. No explanation.

Then one day his jailers tell him he’s free.

His first question? “Why didn’t you kill me?”

Somebody paid to keep him alive, alone, for ten years.

What were they waiting for? And why let him out now?

Goto starts looking for the room they kept him in. One of his leads is the food.

He remembers the taste well enough to go from restaurant to restaurant, trying to find whoever supplied it.

I love that. Ten years of the same miserable routine, and now he’s using it to work his way back.

There are fights. Goto can handle himself.

But what keeps me reading is watching him think, and wondering how much of his next move somebody else has already anticipated.

Because the man responsible keeps involving himself. He calls.

He watches. He sets conditions.

Getting out of the room hasn’t gotten Goto away from him.

And Minegishi makes those first moments outside count.

We’ve been looking at a bed, a television, a meal pushed through a door.

Then suddenly there’s this enormous night sky.

Later, Goto’s eating, smoking, watching people. His face softens.

Then somebody picks a fight with him, and you see him start assessing them.

He’s dangerous, but he can still enjoy being alive.

Now, the ending. I’m not going to give away the reason, but this is where I disagree with a lot of the criticism.

The movie gives you a motive you understand immediately.

With the manga, people get to the explanation and go: seriously? Ten years over that?

I get it. On the surface, it sounds absurd. But that’s what makes it disturbing to me.

Something Goto barely remembered became the thing another man built his life around.

And look at the two of them. Goto loses ten years and still finds things to enjoy.

The man who imprisoned him has been free this whole time, and he spent his life feeding this resentment.

The reason feels too small for what he did. To me, that’s exactly why it works.

If you like a crime story that gives you something to argue about after the mystery’s solved,

read Old Boy, by Garon Tsuchiya and Nobuaki Minegishi.

Goto was locked in that room for ten years.

The man who put him there has been living with this even longer.