When Wishes Go Bad · Part 03
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Sayaka can heal someone she cares about with one wish. The miracle works, which makes the terms Kyubey leaves out even harder to face.
Magica Quartet · Hanokage · William Flanagan · Alexis Eckerman
Injury, violence, death, and emotional distress. The review discusses Sayaka’s wish and leaves the full terms of the bargain and the ending for the story.
Narrated with on-screen captions. Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.
Inside the book
Madoka and Sayaka meet Kyubey, a little creature that offers each of them one wish in exchange for becoming a magical girl and fighting witches. Sayaka sees a chance to heal a violinist who may never play again.
Find your next read after Puella Magi Madoka Magica →
Read the video transcript
A cute little creature offers to grant you any wish. You’re warned the bargain could get you killed. You aren’t told what else you’re giving up.
This is Puella Magi Madoka Magica, with original story by Magica Quartet and art by Hanokage. Part three of When Wishes Go Bad. Madoka and her friend Sayaka meet Kyubey, a little creature offering one wish in exchange for becoming magical girls and fighting witches.
Someone you love is suffering. You can actually do something about it. It’s easy to understand why you might say yes.
Sayaka uses her wish to heal a boy she cares about, a violinist who may never play again. And it works. She gets to hear him play.
That moment matters. She really has made his life better. But then she discovers a cost she was never told about, and starts questioning who she is.
She can risk everything for someone else, yet she can’t forgive herself for being jealous, for wanting affection, for needing something of her own. If you’ve ever felt like being the reliable one means you’re never allowed to fall apart, there’s something painfully familiar here. Kyubey can point to the miracle and say the deal was fulfilled.
The fact that she didn’t understand what she was giving up barely seems to register. And the more you learn about the bargain, the worse that little smiling face looks. Hanokage is especially good with the girls’ expressions.
The excitement, the embarrassment, the effort to keep smiling. You care about these girls before the story asks how much they can take. My one knock: the witches lose a lot of their strangeness on the page.
If you’ve never seen Madoka, start with the anime. But if you want to sit with Sayaka’s story at your own pace, the manga is a mostly faithful retelling, with a few changed scenes and an added closing moment. A great way back into Madoka before the movies or spin-offs.
Watch next
All video reviews →
▶ 2:17When Wishes Go Bad · Part 02
What We Wished For
Six friends get the wishes they made as kids, 35 years after they made them. Ilias Kyriazis finds warmth and dread in the distance between what those children wanted and what the adults need.
Watch review →
▶ 2:39When Wishes Go Bad · Part 01
Eight Billion Genies
You can ask for exactly the right thing and still have to survive everybody else’s choices. Charles Soule and Ryan Browne follow that problem from the first eight seconds to entire societies built around a wish.
Watch review →
▶ 1:38Comics for Halloween · Part 31
Exquisite Corpses: Season One
Twelve killers enter a town on Halloween night. The harder part is remembering the people who live there once you start enjoying the fight.
Watch review →