Puella Magi Madoka Magica cover

Fantasy · Spoiler-light review

Puella Magi Madoka Magica: What Did You Agree to Give Up?

Sayaka can heal someone she cares about with one wish. The miracle works, which makes the terms Kyubey leaves out even harder to face.

The book

Madoka and Sayaka meet Kyubey, a little creature that offers each of them one wish in exchange for becoming a magical girl and fighting witches. Sayaka sees a chance to heal a violinist who may never play again.

Magica Quartet · Hanokage · William Flanagan · Alexis Eckerman

The verdict

Hanokage’s mostly faithful manga gives you time to sit with Sayaka’s choices. I’d start with the anime for a first encounter, especially for the unsettling way it brings the witches to life.

Read it if

You already know the anime and want to revisit the original story at your own pace, or want to spend more time with Sayaka.

Maybe skip if

You want the anime’s audiovisual approach to the witches, or are looking for a continuation of the original story.

Content note

Injury, violence, death, and emotional distress. The review discusses Sayaka’s wish and leaves the full terms of the bargain and the ending for the story.

The miracle works

Kyubey offers a wish in exchange for a dangerous job. Sayaka knows fighting witches could get her killed. Then she looks at someone she cares about who may never play the violin again and realizes she can actually help him.

She makes the wish, and she gets to hear him play. I’m glad the story gives that moment room. The good she does is real, and it stays real even as she begins to understand the cost.

The cost Kyubey leaves out

Sayaka can risk everything for someone else and still struggle to forgive herself for wanting affection or feeling jealous. If you’ve ever felt that being the reliable one means you have to hold yourself together all the time, there’s something painfully familiar in watching her try.

Kyubey can point to the miracle as proof that the deal was fulfilled. Whether Sayaka understood what she was giving up barely seems to register. That little smiling face gets harder to look at the more you learn.

What the manga lets you linger on

Hanokage is especially good at drawing the girls’ embarrassment, excitement, and efforts to keep smiling. You get to know their faces before the story asks how much they can take. The witches lose some of their strangeness on the page, which is part of why I’d begin with the anime.

The original three-volume manga is mostly faithful, with a few changed scenes and an added closing moment. It’s a good way back into Sayaka’s story, especially when you want to stop on a face or a quiet panel and take it in at your own pace.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore fantasy comics

Shelves from Puella Magi Madoka Magica

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

When Wishes Go Bad · Part 03

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

1:59 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next

Keep reading

All reviews →

You’ve reached the latest review in this series. Browse When Wishes Go Bad reviews →