Witch Doctor cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

Witch Doctor: The Monster Is the Diagnosis

Dr. Vincent Morrow treats monsters as medical problems. Brandon Seifert and Lukas Ketner make the diagnosis inventive, disgusting, and far too much fun for a series that only reached two volumes.

The book

Dr. Vincent Morrow runs an occult medical practice in a world where monsters behave like diseases. His cases turn familiar supernatural threats into problems of anatomy, infection, and treatment.

Brandon Seifert · Lukas Ketner

The verdict

Worth picking up for the imagination of its cases and Lukas Ketner’s horrible, convincing biology. The main cases get resolved, but the series stops after two volumes with larger questions about the world still open.

Read it if

You like body horror, monsters with an internal logic, and a brilliant, insufferable doctor who is much too interested in his patients’ symptoms.

Maybe skip if

You need every larger mystery resolved, or would rather keep parasites, unfolding mouths, and impossible anatomy out of your horror.

Content note

Body horror, parasites, blood, invasive procedures, and threats involving infants. The video explains the first vampire case in greater detail; this review keeps its treatment as a discovery for the reader.

House calls for a sick world

The best monster hunter for this job carries a scalpel. In Witch Doctor, the world is sick, monsters are diseases, and Dr. Vincent Morrow makes house calls.

Brandon Seifert takes that premise seriously enough to make the cases work as medical puzzles. Vampires, demonic possession, and whatever has replaced the baby in a crib all have symptoms worth examining.

Morrow has the pleasure and difficulty of a doctor who is brilliant, insufferable, and far too excited about whatever is growing inside you. The comparison with an occult Dr. House gives a useful sense of the company you will be keeping.

The symptoms are clues

The vampire case is a good example of the book’s imagination. The familiar fangs are only the visible problem. Morrow understands the creature as a parasite with a particular relationship to the body it occupies.

Once the monster has a biology, treatment becomes a question. How does it feed? What does it need? What would persuade it to leave? The fun comes from watching a diagnosis become a plan, so I would leave the details of that plan for the comic.

Figuring it out also means getting close enough to get bitten. Paramedic Eric Gast helps keep Morrow alive. Penny Dreadful is both one of his patients and his anesthesiologist, which tells you something about how this practice operates.

Anatomy you almost believe

Lukas Ketner draws the anatomy just far enough to make the horrible ideas feel workable. Mouths unfold. Organs become creatures. Something that appeared to be part of a person turns out to have a life of its own.

The drawing gives Seifert’s explanations something solid to attach to. A case can be funny and repulsive at the same time because the organism feels like something Morrow might actually examine.

That is where the series earns its appeal. The medical premise keeps producing images and practical questions. The explanation makes you more interested in looking, even when looking is an unpleasant idea.

I wish there were more appointments

By the second volume, Morrow becomes the patient. Someone deliberately infects him, and he has to work out what is eating him alive. The person who usually explains the danger has to live inside it.

The series stopped after two collected volumes. Its main cases get resolutions, but the larger questions about this world remain open. That is a real caveat if you need a fully closed series.

I would still pick it up. There is too much imagination and too much horrible biology here to pass over. I just wish there were more appointments.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore horror comics

Shelves from Witch Doctor

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 29

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:14 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Clean Room cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 30

Clean Room

Gail Simone · Jon Davis-Hunt · Walter Geovani · Sanya Anwar · Quinton Winter · Todd Klein

Astrid Mueller looks like a cult leader because she is one. The uncomfortable part of Gail Simone’s horror comic is what happens when you begin to believe she may also be right.

Read Part 30 →