Eight Billion Genies cover

Fantasy · Spoiler-light review

Eight Billion Genies: Everybody Else Gets One Too

You can ask for exactly the right thing and still have to survive everybody else’s choices. Charles Soule and Ryan Browne follow that problem from the first eight seconds to entire societies built around a wish.

The book

Every person on Earth receives a genie and one wish at the same moment. A bartender protects a Michigan bar from wishes made outside it, giving its occupants shelter while the world around them changes beyond recognition.

Charles Soule · Ryan Browne · Chris Crank

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

An inventive, emotionally grounded complete story that follows its premise far beyond the first burst of chaos. Its expanding timescale is also the caveat: some characters and ideas could use more time before the next jump forward.

Read it if

You like a simple fantasy premise explored through social consequences, intimate choices, and impossible changes of scale. The complete story is collected in one book.

Maybe skip if

You need every character thread closed, prefer a steady timescale, or want wish fulfillment without difficult questions about how other people will use the same power.

Content note

Violence, death, bereavement, coercive family relationships, and disaster. This review discusses the setup and selected early wishes but leaves the ending and ultimate resolution for the book.

The person you would least trust with a wish

What would you wish for if you could have anything? Now think about the person you would least trust with that power. Eight Billion Genies gives both of you a wish at exactly the same time. So does everyone else.

Before you have finished deciding, the Earth has become a cube and impossible creatures are tearing through the streets. Someone else’s wish can change the conditions around yours.

That is the problem that makes Charles Soule and Ryan Browne’s premise so compelling. Choosing wisely does not remove you from the consequences of everyone else’s decisions. You still have to survive long enough to use the chance you have been given.

An ordinary bar becomes shelter

We begin in a Michigan bar. The bartender uses his wish to protect it from wishes made outside, and an ordinary night out becomes shelter from the end of the world.

Inside, Ed is drinking through his grief while his son worries about him. When he gets the chance to bring his wife back, you understand the temptation. Other people want their families safe or want someone to love them back, and those wishes can collide.

One father even uses his wish to make sure his children cannot use theirs without his approval. An unused wish can become a bargaining chip, a weapon, or something another person pressures you to spend. I love how thoroughly the comic follows those consequences.

A world that will not hold still

Ryan Browne makes that changing world feel unpredictable. Inside the bar, the drawing is scratchy and the colors are muted. Then grinning, cartoonish genies appear with starfields inside their bodies and blue light spilling onto the people around them.

Outside, the pages erupt into bright color and impossible creatures. Returning to the bar feels like stepping back into somewhere you recognize. The familiar room becomes a way to feel how much has changed beyond it.

The scale of the drawing makes the premise visible, but the faces keep it attached to people. The story can move toward an altered world without losing the particular ache behind someone wanting a person back.

From seconds to centuries

The story keeps pulling further back. It starts with the first eight seconds, then moves through minutes, hours, days, and eventually centuries. Entire societies grow around decisions made in a moment.

That scale is also my frustration. Some plotlines felt unresolved, and there were characters and ideas I wanted more time with before the story jumped ahead again. The widening view creates possibilities while asking you to leave some people sooner than you might want.

But watching the world change, and watching people keep finding reasons to care for one another inside it, gives the simple premise emotional weight. It is eight issues, one complete story, and the first review in When Wishes Go Bad. Would you spend your wish immediately, or hold onto it?

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from Eight Billion Genies

Shelves from Eight Billion Genies

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

When Wishes Go Bad · Part 01

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:39 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
What We Wished For cover

When Wishes Go Bad · Part 02

What We Wished For

Ilias Kyriazis · Nikki Spanou · Tom Williams

Six friends get the wishes they made as kids, 35 years after they made them. Ilias Kyriazis finds warmth and dread in the distance between what those children wanted and what the adults need.

Read Part 02 →