The Low, Low Woods cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

The Low, Low Woods: What the Town Wants You to Forget

Missing hours divide two best friends in a town that looks beautiful, feels unhealthy, and has learned to live with terrible things.

The book

El and Octavia wake in an empty movie theater with no memory of the film or the hours that have passed. In their Pennsylvania mining town, women have been losing pieces of their lives for years.

Carmen Maria Machado · Dani · Tamra Bonvillain · Steve Wands

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A complete horror story whose mystery matters because of the friendship inside it. The missing hours are frightening, but the disagreement over what to do next gives the book its emotional weight. Dani and Tamra Bonvillain make this a place worth looking at even when you want to leave.

Read it if

You want queer protagonists, unsettling small-town folklore, expressive art, and a story about memory, friendship, and the harm a community chooses not to confront.

Maybe skip if

You want light Halloween fun or a straightforward monster hunt. Sexual violence and the loss of bodily autonomy are central to the horror, even when the story approaches them indirectly.

Content note

Sexual violence, coercion, memory loss, misogyny, body horror, disturbing imagery, and strong language. This review discusses the premise and themes without explaining the central mystery or ending.

The hours you cannot account for

Imagine waking up in an empty movie theater with your best friend. The movie is over, neither of you remembers watching it, and there is mud on her shoes. The opening of The Low, Low Woods makes a small, ordinary detail feel like evidence of something neither girl can explain.

The opening makes an ordinary movie theater feel wrong through empty space and the girls’ missing time.The Low, Low Woods · Carmen Maria Machado, writing; Dani, art; Tamra Bonvillain, colors; Steve Wands, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

El and Octavia live in Shudder-to-Think, Pennsylvania, an old mining town where fires burn underground and smoke rises through cracks in the road. Strange creatures belong to the landscape they grew up in. The girls can argue about something moving through the woods, climb back onto their bicycle, and keep going. The missing hours are harder to shrug off.

The same experience, different needs

What pulled me in is that El and Octavia do not agree on what they need from each other. El wants to find out why this happened. Octavia wants to get out of town. They have shared something frightening, but that does not automatically give them a shared way of dealing with it. That is a hard place to be with your best friend.

Machado lets them tell us stories about their lives: how they met, things they have read, moments they remember. We get to know them through their memories while they are trying to recover the ones they have lost. Their teasing and frustration give you a sense of the years they spent together before this story began.

That friendship gives the book room to breathe. A bicycle ride or an awkward conversation can matter as much as an encounter with something impossible. The girls have lives beyond the mystery, which makes the intrusion into those lives more disturbing.

A place you keep stopping to look at

Dani fills the woods with crooked branches and heavy black shadows. A bicycle headlight opens a small circle in the darkness, leaving enough unseen that you begin searching the page yourself. The drawing gives you a reason to linger without making the place feel safe.

The change from a distant animal shape to isolated details turns the woodland encounter into something harder to recognize.The Low, Low Woods · Carmen Maria Machado, writing; Dani, art; Tamra Bonvillain, colors; Steve Wands, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

The faces are just as important. A sideways look or a tightened mouth tells you when a conversation has gone wrong. Those reactions keep the friendship readable even as the world around the girls becomes harder to understand.

Tamra Bonvillain’s colors make the town beautiful and unhealthy at once: cold blue in the empty cinema, purple and pink in the woods, orange firelight across faces. I kept stopping to look at places I would be desperate to leave.

Dani’s slanted viewpoints and Bonvillain’s purples make Shudder-to-Think feel unsettled even before a creature appears.The Low, Low Woods · Carmen Maria Machado, writing; Dani, art; Tamra Bonvillain, colors; Steve Wands, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

What a town asks its girls to carry

A strange creature is something you can see. How do you protect yourself from something you cannot even remember? That question makes the missing hours more unsettling than any individual monster.

The supernatural gives shape to what this town takes from women and how badly it wants them to forget. El and Octavia are growing up inside a history they had no part in making. Now they have to decide what to do with it, and what they can ask of each other along the way.

The Low, Low Woods collects the complete six-issue story in one volume. Choose it for the friendship as much as the mystery, and give the art time to work. Would you want those missing hours back, even if you were afraid of what you would find?

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from The Low, Low Woods

Shelves from The Low, Low Woods

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 20

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:59 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Long Lost cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 21

Long Lost

Matthew Erman · Lisa Sterle

Matthew Erman and Lisa Sterle send two sisters into the woods, but the trouble they have talking to each other is what makes the journey worth following.

Read Part 21 →