Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1 cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1: The Sadness Beneath the Horror

Rainbow Sprinkles can make you recoil. What lingers is how much it makes you care before things go wrong.

The book

Four horror stories follow ordinary people whose lives are already going wrong, linked by a recurring, sinister ice cream man.

W. Maxwell Prince · Martín Morazzo · Chris O’Halloran

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A strong starting point for readers who like the uneasy little worlds of The Twilight Zone and horror with an emotional cost.

Read it if

You want impossible events and unsettling images, with addiction, regret, grief, and loneliness doing much of the damage.

Maybe skip if

You want reassuring endings or a single ongoing adventure. Its cruelty and changing casts may leave you wanting something different.

Content note

Graphic violence, body horror, drug addiction, death, and grief. This review discusses premises and visual approach without revealing the stories’ endings.

People already hurting

Ice Cream Man has some deeply disturbing images, but the fear often starts before anything supernatural happens. A couple struggling with heroin addiction still talks about getting clean and moving to Arizona. A musician is a one-hit wonder who never had another hit. A man delivers a eulogy for a best friend he had not spoken to in two years.

“Once you have started hoping for someone, the next turn feels more cruel.”
Small changes in faces and framing carry an otherwise ordinary exchange. The clean drawing makes every glance easy to follow.Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1 · W. Maxwell Prince (writer); Martín Morazzo (art); Chris O’Halloran (colors). Artwork © its respective rights holders. Publisher preview.

Those details give the first volume its weight. These people have histories, disappointed hopes, and things left unsaid. Their problems would matter even in a story without monsters. W. Maxwell Prince gives you enough time with them to want something better: a small kindness, another chance, an ordinary day that does not end badly.

Then something impossible makes an already painful situation worse. Once you have started hoping for someone, the next turn feels more cruel. The unease comes partly from wondering what the book will show you, and partly from worrying about the person who has to experience it.

The Twilight Zone feeling

Rainbow Sprinkles collects the first four issues. Each brings a different central situation and cast, with the ice cream man providing a recurring presence. That makes this an approachable place to begin: there is no large continuity puzzle to solve before the stories can affect you.

The comparison with The Twilight Zone is about how quickly familiar life becomes unreliable. You recognize a neighborhood, a relationship, or a private disappointment. Something slips. Suddenly, you no longer know what rules the world is playing by. Going in without knowing where each story leads preserves that disorientation.

The changing focus also makes the volume feel restless. Just as you have absorbed one person’s troubles, you enter another life. That variety is part of the appeal, though it means readers who want a long attachment to one protagonist may prefer a more continuous horror story.

Clean lines, disturbing clarity

Martín Morazzo’s precise linework makes the strangest events feel solid. Bodies, faces, and ordinary objects remain readable even when what is happening to them makes no sense. You do not have to fight through visual murk to understand an unsettling image; its clarity is part of what makes it difficult to shake.

An ordinary neighborhood, held in crisp lines and cool blue beneath a peach-colored sky. The inviting setting gives the later horror somewhere recognizable to intrude.Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1 · W. Maxwell Prince (writer); Martín Morazzo (art); Chris O’Halloran (colors). Artwork © its respective rights holders. Publisher preview.

Chris O’Halloran’s colors can be bright and inviting. A neighborhood scene can almost let you settle in, and then the same colorful world gives you something you wish you had not seen. That contrast lets the horror intrude on the everyday instead of keeping it safely at a distance in a permanently shadowy setting.

The quieter panels matter just as much. A face, a posture, or someone alone in a room gives the suffering a human scale. These images make the characters worth worrying about before the spectacle arrives. Sometimes they are also the images that stay with you afterward.

Who should read it?

Try this if you want short horror stories that can leave you heartsick, or if ordinary regret unsettles you as much as body horror. The emotional bleakness is central to the recommendation. Even when the world treats these people as disposable, the attention paid to their hopes makes their suffering matter.

If you need horror to provide a dependable sense of justice, this may be a difficult fit. Its uncertainty extends to whether a character will get any relief. The compact stories are easy to begin, but that does not make them light reading.

Start with Volume One: Rainbow Sprinkles. It establishes the combination that makes the book distinctive: recognizable hurt, an unstable world, and artwork that makes the impossible painfully clear.

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1

Shelves from Ice Cream Man, Vol. 1

Page structures that become part of the story7 booksFamiliar comforts becoming sources of dread6 books

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 01

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

2:54 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Through the Woods cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 02

Through the Woods

Written and illustrated by Emily Carroll

Emily Carroll turns the familiar comforts of a fairy tale into reasons to keep the light on.

Read Part 02 →