House of Penance cover

Horror · Spoiler-light review

House of Penance: When the Hammers Cannot Stop

A house keeps growing around people who cannot put their guilt down. Ian Bertram and Dave Stewart make that burden feel alive inside the walls.

The book

In this fictional nightmare drawn from the legends of Sarah Winchester, construction never stops. Sarah fears the victims of the rifles that made her fortune, while the men building her house bring their own histories of bloodshed.

Peter J. Tomasi · Ian Bertram · Dave Stewart · Nate Piekos

Book page, reading status & discussions →

The verdict

A visually extraordinary horror story with a tender moment at its center. The house and its spreading red imagery are worth lingering over, but the people trying to live with what they have done are what make the nightmare hurt.

Read it if

You want intricate, unsettling drawing, gothic architecture, guilt made visible, and a complete story that finds compassion among damaged people.

Maybe skip if

You want a factual account of Sarah Winchester, a tidy explanation of every apparition, or clean, restrained horror imagery. This is a feverish fictional treatment of the legends.

Content note

Gun violence, blood, disturbing bodily imagery, grief, the loss of a child, and psychological distress. This review discusses early scenes and the visual approach without revealing the ending.

A house filled with the sound of gunfire

Sarah Winchester takes every worker’s gun. Then she fills her house with the sound of gunfire. The hammers strike with great BLAMs, and she believes that if they stop, the dead will get in. That contradiction gives House of Penance its terrible rhythm.

Bertram introduces the house as a mass of roofs, towers, and ongoing work, with hammering filling the air.House of Penance · Peter J. Tomasi, writing; Ian Bertram, art; Dave Stewart, colors; Nate Piekos, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

She has already lost her husband and daughter. Now she fears the people killed by the rifles that made her fortune are coming for her. An unfinished corner of her bedroom is enough to terrify her, so the house never stops growing. Peter J. Tomasi builds this nightmare around the legends of Sarah Winchester; it should not be mistaken for a factual biography.

A staircase to nowhere makes the building’s strange purpose visible, while the lettering keeps the construction noise present.House of Penance · Peter J. Tomasi, writing; Ian Bertram, art; Dave Stewart, colors; Nate Piekos, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

Someone else reaches into the water

The men swinging Sarah’s hammers have blood on their hands. Warren Peck is one of them. When he scrubs his hands beneath the tap, red winds around his fingers. You do not need to know whether that blood is real to understand his desperation.

Then Sarah reaches into the water and touches his hand. For a moment, he is not facing it alone. That small gesture is what stays with me in a book with so much visual noise.

A small gesture of contact interrupts the surrounding horror, giving the two characters a moment of shared recognition.House of Penance · Peter J. Tomasi, writing; Ian Bertram, art; Dave Stewart, colors; Nate Piekos, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

Sarah is trying to keep the dead out, but the hammering also makes these men hear the violence they have committed. It is their penance, and hers. The scene allows her to recognize another person’s suffering without asking us to trust the solution she has built around it.

The red gets into everything

Ian Bertram makes skin look cracked and worn. Broken ink marks accumulate across faces and bodies, giving people the same battered intensity as their surroundings. A gentle touch stands out because so much around it looks rough and damaged.

Dave Stewart’s red keeps spreading: around a finger, up a staircase, through the house. Something that belongs inside a body grows through the walls. The architecture becomes difficult to separate from the people’s fear and guilt.

Red spreads across the image like something the buildings cannot contain, making guilt and haunting part of the landscape.House of Penance · Peter J. Tomasi, writing; Ian Bertram, art; Dave Stewart, colors; Nate Piekos, lettering. Artwork © its respective rights holders. Book and creator details.

This is a book to slow down for. Bertram’s crowded spaces and restless lines make looking an active part of reading. The art gives the house a pressure that an explanation alone could not supply.

Wanting peace without trusting the cure

You do not have to trust Sarah’s solution to want these people to find some peace. That is the emotional space the book opens up. Their fear can be frightening to witness without making them impossible to care about.

House of Penance is a complete six-issue story, collected by Dark Horse. Choose it for the drawing, the color, and the moments of recognition inside the nightmare. Can you find peace if you will not let the noise stop?

Find your next comic

Follow what you liked.

Ground Floor Comics matches you with comics by what you actually liked about a book. Each shelf follows a different part of its appeal.

Explore from House of Penance

Shelves from House of Penance

We’re still reviewing this book’s shelf connections. Try the recommendations above while we build its coverage.

Watch the video review

Comics for Halloween · Part 22

Narrated by Josh Brown with on-screen captions.

1:47 · Narrated by Josh Brown

Artwork belongs to its respective creators and rights holders.

Follow Ground Floor Comics for more short reviews.

Open watch page and more videos →

Back to what to read next
Old Haunts cover

Comics for Halloween · Part 23

Old Haunts

Ollie Masters · Rob Williams · Laurence Campbell · Lee Loughridge · Sal Cipriano

Three gangsters have a chance to retire rich. The people they buried have other plans, and the friendship that carried them this far is becoming dangerous.

Read Part 23 →